Make It Even vs a Spreadsheet

Plenty of groups start with a shared Google Sheet or an Excel file. It is free and flexible, and for two people splitting rent it can be enough. The trouble starts when the group grows, the currencies multiply, or someone fat-fingers a formula and the totals quietly go wrong.

Make It Even handles the parts a spreadsheet makes you do by hand. Splits are calculated to the cent and always sum to the total. Multiple currencies each lock their own day's exchange rate, so you never have to maintain a rate column or re-key conversions. Debt simplification figures out the fewest payments to square everyone up.

A sheet doesn't nudge anyone to pay, doesn't fit a phone screen, and doesn't catch the row you deleted by accident. The comparison below is about where automation earns its keep.

FeatureMake It Evena spreadsheet
Free tier & adsFree: 3 active groups, 5 friends, no adsFree with a Google/Microsoft account
Pricing modelFree, with Pro at $3.99/mo or $29.99/yrFree, or bundled with an office suite
Split typesEqual, exact, percentage, shares; itemized on ProWhatever you build by hand
Multi-currency & FX14 currencies; each expense locks that day's rateManual rate columns; easy to get stale
Receipt scanningAI receipt scan on ProType every line yourself
Debt simplificationYes, fewest paymentsBuild the netting logic yourself
Group budgetsMonthly group budgets includedPossible, but you maintain it
Settle-up & paymentsPayPal / Venmo / Cash App linksNone; copy figures manually
Error safetySplits always sum to the totalOne broken formula skews everything
Data export / privacyGDPR export and delete; CSV on ProYou own the file
Platform & setupHosted, installable PWA, mobile-firstEditable on phone, but clunky

Why people switch to Make It Even

No broken formulas

Make It Even computes every split so the parts always add up to the total. There is no cell to overwrite and no SUM range to forget.

Exchange rates handled for you

Each expense locks its own day's FX rate. You never maintain a rate column or worry that an old trip silently re-converts.

Actually gets people to pay

A spreadsheet records debts but can't collect them. Make It Even shows who owes whom and links out to PayPal, Venmo, or Cash App to settle.

Made for the table, not the desk

Adding an expense the moment it happens is a few taps on your phone, instead of pinch-zooming into a tiny cell.

Scan instead of type

With Pro, snap a receipt and let the scanner pull the amount, date, and items, rather than transcribing them row by row.

Questions

Why not just use a free spreadsheet?
For a simple two-person split it works, but spreadsheets break on currency conversion, manual formulas, and getting people to actually pay.
Does Make It Even handle currencies better than a sheet?
Yes. It supports 14 currencies and locks each expense's exchange rate to its date, so you never maintain rates by hand.
Can I get my data out?
Yes. Pro includes CSV export, and any account can request a full GDPR export or deletion.
Will it catch my math mistakes?
Splits are always calculated to sum exactly to the total, so there's no stray formula to throw the numbers off.
Is it free to start?
Yes. The free tier covers 3 active groups and 5 friends with no ads and no daily limits.

Related reading

More comparisons